Skip to main content

Medical Hill Healthcare Center vs. Piedmont Gardens Health Facility

Medical Hill Healthcare Center and Piedmont Gardens Health Facility both are nursing homes in Oakland, California. Medical Hill Healthcare Center starts at $1,500 per month, $14,333 (91%) less than Piedmont Gardens Health Facility at $15,833.

Based on 31 published reviews, the newest from April 2026. No home pays to rank higher.

At a glance

Starting price per month

$1,500

Medical Hill Healthcare CenterLower starting price

$15,833

Piedmont Gardens Health Facility

Review rating

4.3/5

Medical Hill Healthcare Center

4.5/5

Piedmont Gardens Health FacilityGoogle

Licensed size

124 beds

Medical Hill Healthcare Center

94 beds

Piedmont Gardens Health Facility

Nearest hospital

0.2 mi

Medical Hill Healthcare CenterCloser to a hospital

0.4 mi

Piedmont Gardens Health Facility

Distance apart

1 mi

Between the two homes

Medical Hill Healthcare Center

Piedmont Gardens Health Facility

Where each home stands out

Medical Hill Healthcare Center

  • Lower starting price
  • Closer to a hospital

Piedmont Gardens Health Facility

  • Rated higher on Google
  • More detail on activities & social life
  • More detail on outdoor time
  • More detail on outings & transportation

Cost and key facts

Price

From $1,500Lower starting price

per month · Caring

From $15,833

per month

Review rating

4.5/5Rated higher on Google

Google · 73 reviews

Official rating

5/5 · Much above average

Medicare overall rating

5/5 · Much above average

Medicare overall rating

Size

124 beds

94 beds

State license

Active

CA 020000110

Active

CA 020000088

Ways to pay

Managed care plan, Medicaid (Medi-Cal), Medicare, Medicare Advantage +1 more

Managed care plan, Medicaid (Medi-Cal), Medicare, Medicare Advantage +1 more

Assisted living · studio

Not published

From $2,308

per month · SeniorAdvisor

Independent living · studio

Not published

From $4,626

per month

Independent living · one bedroom

Not published

From $5,491

per month

Independent living · two bedroom

Not published

From $7,461

per month

Ratings on every review site

Caring

3.6/5Rated higher on Caring

20 reviews

Google

4.5/5Rated higher on Google

73 reviews

Inspections and safety

State inspections

36 visits

Since November 2023 · latest October 28, 2026

25 visits

Since November 2023 · latest July 23, 2026

Citations

26

Federal inspectors, since november 2023

28

Federal inspectors, since november 2023

Complaints received

41

5 substantiated

19

4 substantiated

Nearest hospital

0.2 miCloser to a hospital

Alta Bates Summit Medical Center

0.4 mi

Kaiser Foundation Hospital - Oakland/Richmond

Care and amenities

Care offered

Nursing homeAssisted living
Nursing homeAssisted livingContinuing care retirement communityIndependent livingMemory care

Only at one home (20 vs 45)

12-16 hour nursingActivity CenterAir conditioningBed sore careClubs & CommunitiesCommunity activitiesFeeding assistanceFinancial servicesFitness programsInsulin injectionsMeal preparation and serviceMental health care
8 more
Mental wellnessMusic programsOstomy careOutdoor AreasSecure unitTransport arrangedVentilator careWalking help
24-hour nursingAccessible showersActivities Off-siteActivities On-siteAssisted LivingBath TubsBeauticianCommunal DiningComputer RoomCPAP or BiPAPDementia waiverExtra staffing
33 more
Fitness equipmentFree transportationGuest MealsHair salonHigh Acuity CareHospice CareHospice care on siteIn-unit kitchenIV therapyLifelong learningLinen ServicesLoungesMeal PreparationMeals ProvidedMemory careMemory Care ServicesMild cognitive impairmentNear public transitOff-site worshipOn-site worshipOutpatient servicesParking LotParkinson's carePharmacy on-sitePreventive screeningResident parkingShort staysSkilled NursingTransportationTransportation at CostVA benefits helpVegetarianWorks with your doctors

At both homes (62)

24-hour supervisionActivity roomAll day diningAllergy-awareArts roomAssistance with bathingAssistance with dressingAssistance with transfersBathing assistanceBusiness roomCable TVClimate control
50 more
ConciergeDaily activitiesDaily living helpDiabetes careDiabetes dietDining roomDressing assistanceEmergency call systemFamily supportFurnishedGame roomGardenGluten-freeGymHousekeepingIncontinence careKitchenetteLaundryLibraryMedication helpMove-in helpMovie nightsMovie roomMusic programNon-ambulatory careNurse on site 24/7Occupational therapyOutdoor programsOutdoor spaceOxygenPalliative carePhysical therapyPrivate bathroomProfessional chefRehab therapyResident councilResident-run clubsRestaurant-style diningRides to the doctorRoom phoneSpaSpecial dietsSpeech therapySprinklers throughoutStaff give medicationTransport and parkingWalking pathsWheelchair usersWi-FiWound care

Daily life

Dining & meals

ASeveral accounts

“Her only complaint was the meal preparation not being up to her high culinary standards, but I take responsibility for that by sending her to cooking class LOL.”
Google, Apr 30, 2026
1 more review · 9 listed features
“And the food is not fit for human consumption.”
Google, Nov 30, 2025
  • All day dining
  • Allergy-aware
  • Diabetes diet
  • Dining room
  • Gluten-free
  • Meal preparation and service
  • Professional chef
  • Restaurant-style dining
  • Special diets

ASeveral accounts

“The food is good.”
Caring, May 7, 2025
8 more reviews · 12 listed features
“The dining area looked OK.”
Caring, Oct 14, 2022
“They have a lot of nice people who interact with people in the dining room, people in nursing care, and people who drive people around to appointments.”
Caring, Jun 10, 2016
“The food was good.”
Caring, Feb 1, 2016
“I didn't pay a great deal of attention, and I didn't have a meal there, so I have no evaluation of their dining area.”
Caring, Jul 4, 2015
“The dining facility looked very good, and what they offered looked very good.”
Caring, May 3, 2015
“They’ll supply the food for us.”
Caring, Nov 17, 2014
“The food was good and adequate.”
Caring, Nov 26, 2013
“My friend was a very finicky eater and was often unhappy with the food.”
Caring, Jun 27, 2012
  • All day dining
  • Allergy-aware
  • Communal Dining
  • Diabetes diet
  • Dining room
  • Gluten-free
  • Guest Meals
  • Meals Provided
  • Professional chef
  • Restaurant-style dining
  • Vegetarian
  • Meal Preparation

Activities & social life

BTwo sources of detail

“They have monthly activities to keep my dad busy and they are nice and clean!”
Google, Apr 13, 2026
11 listed features
  • Community activities
  • Fitness programs
  • Movie nights
  • Music program
  • Music programs
  • Outdoor programs
  • Resident-run clubs
  • Daily activities
  • Activity Center
  • Activity room
  • Clubs & Communities

ASeveral accountsMore detail

“They have lots of staff usually of intellectual nature; there are lectures, they have a library, they received periodicals, they have music available, and they take people to the theater.”
Caring, Dec 6, 2016
3 more reviews · 13 listed features
“They have a lot of music, discussion groups, farmer's market, and the residents actually have a fund where they supplement the activities themselves.”
Caring, Jun 10, 2016
“They had quite a few of activities for different things.”
Caring, Nov 17, 2014
“People who live there have created clubs and participate in outings to local shopping areas, etc.”
Caring, Jun 27, 2012
  • Activities Off-site
  • Activities On-site
  • Lifelong learning
  • Off-site worship
  • On-site worship
  • Fitness equipment
  • Movie nights
  • Music program
  • Outdoor programs
  • Resident-run clubs
  • Hair salon
  • Daily activities
  • Activity room

Outdoor time

CLimited detail

5 listed features
  • Outdoor programs
  • Garden
  • Outdoor Areas
  • Outdoor space
  • Walking paths

ASeveral accountsMore detail

“My sister-in-law is a resident of Piedmont Gardens CCRC.”
Caring, May 7, 2025
14 more reviews · 5 listed features
“The experience she & I had with Piedmont Gardens was incredibly challenging.”
Caring, May 18, 2023
“Piedmont Gardens CCRC was more in the heart of the city.”
Caring, Oct 14, 2022
“I can't afford Piedmont Gardens; it's too expensive.”
Caring, Jul 25, 2021
“I have a friend who lives at Piedmont Gardens.”
Caring, Dec 6, 2016
“We ended up going with Piedmont Gardens.”
Caring, Jun 10, 2016
“The older section of Piedmont Gardens looked more gracious.”
Caring, Feb 1, 2016
“Piedmont Gardens was OK.”
Caring, Jul 4, 2015
“We visited Piedmont Gardens, and we really like this place.”
Caring, May 8, 2015
“Piedmont Gardens was OK.”
Caring, Nov 17, 2014
“I was happy with Piedmont Gardens.”
Caring, Nov 26, 2013
“If I absolutely could not care for my parents on my own when they get older, or if they needed some type of medical assistance, I would definitely look for a place like Piedmont Gardens Nursing Home.”
Caring, Sep 27, 2012
“My experience with Piedmont Gardens was positive.”
Caring, Jun 27, 2012
“Piedmont Gardens, a five-star hotel specifically designed for seniors.”
Caring, Dec 3, 2011
“Piedmont Gardens have/had lots of screamers.”
Caring, May 19, 2011
  • Outdoor programs
  • Garden
  • Outdoor space
  • Outdoor space
  • Walking paths

Quiet & privacy

?Ask on tour

?Ask on tour

Outings & transportation

CLimited detail

2 listed features
  • Transport arranged
  • Transport and parking

BTwo sources of detailMore detail

“People who live there have created clubs and participate in outings to local shopping areas, etc.”
Caring, Jun 27, 2012
6 listed features
  • Free transportation
  • Transportation
  • Near public transit
  • Resident parking
  • Transport and parking
  • Transportation at Cost

Pets & visiting animals

?Ask on tour

CLimited detailMore detail

3 listed features
  • Cats Allowed
  • Dogs Allowed
  • Pet Care Available

Medical Hill Healthcare Center or Piedmont Gardens Health Facility? Common questions

Ask on your visits

More comparisons in Oakland

Get help with my shortlist