Skip to main content

Coterie Cathedral Hill vs. Portola Gardens

Coterie Cathedral Hill and Portola Gardens both offer assisted living in San Francisco, California. Portola Gardens starts at $3,695 per month, $6,205 (63%) less than Coterie Cathedral Hill at $9,900.

Based on 38 published reviews, the newest from August 2026. No home pays to rank higher.

At a glance

Starting price per month

$9,900

Coterie Cathedral Hill

$3,695

Portola GardensLower starting price

Review rating

4.9/5

Coterie Cathedral HillGoogle

4.8/5

Portola Gardens

Licensed size

260 beds

Coterie Cathedral Hill

132 beds

Portola Gardens

Serious citations

5

Coterie Cathedral Hill

4

Portola GardensFewer serious citations

Nearest hospital

0.1 mi

Coterie Cathedral HillCloser to a hospital

0.9 mi

Portola Gardens

Distance apart

4.1 mi

Between the two homes

Coterie Cathedral Hill

Portola Gardens

Where each home stands out

Coterie Cathedral Hill

  • Rated higher on Google
  • Closer to a hospital
  • More detail on outings & transportation

Portola Gardens

  • Lower starting price
  • Fewer serious citations
  • More detail on outdoor time
  • More detail on quiet & privacy

Cost and key facts

Price

From $9,900

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

From $3,695Lower starting price

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Review rating

4.9/5Rated higher on Google

Google · 105 reviews

Official rating

5 serious citations in 3 years

State inspection

4 serious citations in 3 years

State inspection

Size

260 beds

132 beds

State license

Active

CA 385601116

Active

CA 385601045

Ways to pay

Private pay

Medicaid (Medi-Cal), Medicaid waiver (Assisted Living Waiver), Private pay

Assisted living · shared room

Not published

From $3,695

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Assisted living · private room

Not published

From $4,595

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Memory care · shared room

From $13,495

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

From $5,795Lower price for this room

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Memory care · private room

Not published

From $7,595

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Assisted living · studio

From $9,900

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Not published

Independent living · studio

From $9,900

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Not published

Assisted living · one bedroom

From $10,500

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Not published

Independent living · one bedroom

From $11,900

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Not published

Memory care · semi-private room

From $16,195

per month · Caring

Not published

Independent living · two bedroom

From $17,500

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Not published

Memory care · studio

From $18,000

per month · Caring

Not published

Assisted living · two bedroom

From $18,300

per month · Seniorly / CareScout

Not published

Ratings on every review site

A Place for Mom

Not published

CareScout

5/5Rated higher on CareScout

1 review

Caring

4.9/5Rated higher on Caring

12 reviews

Google

4.9/5Rated higher on Google

105 reviews

Seniorly

5/5Rated higher on Seniorly

1 review

SeniorAdvisor

Not published

Inspections and safety

Serious (Type A) citations

4Fewer serious citations

Since November 2023

Complaints received

Nearest hospital

0.1 miCloser to a hospital

California Pacific Medical Center- Van Ness Campus

0.9 mi

Jewish Home & Rehab Center

Licensed since

February 2022

April 2019

Care and amenities

Care offered

Assisted livingMemory careIndependent living
Assisted livingMemory care

Only at one home (100 vs 11)

24-hour nursingAdventist ServicesAnytime DiningArt ClassesBar or PubBarberBBQs or picnicsBeauticianBirthday PartiesBook ClubBridge ClubCable or satellite TV
88 more
CaféCard clubCatholic ServicesCentral FireplaceChair yogaChoirChristian ServicesCommunal DiningComputer or media roomCooking ClassesCooking ClubCovered ParkingCPAP or BiPAPCurrent Events ClubDancesDay tripsFireplaceFull kitchenGardening ClubGrillGround Floor UnitsGuest MealsHair salonHandicap AccessibleHappy HourHearing or vision supportHoliday PartiesIn-unit kitchenIndoor AtriumIntergenerational eventsInternational cuisineIslamic ServicesJewish ServicesKaraokeLifelong learningLight Therapy ProgramsLive musicLive showsLive Well ProgramsLounge barLow sodiumMain Street ShopsMeeting RoomMenu highlightsMormon/LDS ServicesNear public transitNo SugarNurse on site 24/7On-site storeOrganicOutingsOxygenParking LotPatioPet-focused ProgramsPhysical therapyPianoPiano or organPoolPool or hot tubPrivate Dining RoomProtestant ServicesQi GongRaised Garden BedsRehab therapyReligious servicesReminiscence ProgramsResident musiciansRides to the doctorRoom ServiceSecure unitSpecial Dining ProgramsSports / cocktail loungeStaff give medicationStretching ClassesTai ChiTalks and classesToileting assistanceTransportationTrivia GamesTV LoungeVeganVisiting clergyVisiting RabbiWalking ClubWandering riskWater AerobicsWine Tasting
12-16 hour nursingAwake overnight staffChallenging behaviorsHospice residents acceptedHospice waiverInsulin injectionsKosherKosher mealsMental health careOff-site worshipParkinson's care

At both homes (84)

24-hour supervisionAccessible showersActivities Off-siteActivities On-siteActivity roomAir conditioningAll day diningAllergy-awareArts roomAssistance with bathingAssistance with dressingAssistance with transfers
72 more
Bathing assistanceBed-bound residentsBusiness roomCable TVClimate controlCommunity activitiesConciergeDaily activitiesDaily living helpDementia careDementia waiverDiabetes careDiabetes dietDining roomDressing assistanceEmergency call systemExtra staffingFaith BasedFamily supportFitness programsFree transportationFurnishedGame roomGardenGluten-freeGymHelp booking appointmentsHigh Acuity CareHousekeepingIncontinence careKitchenetteLaundryLibraryLoungesMeal preparation and serviceMeals ProvidedMeals, snacks and prescribed dietsMedication helpMemory careMemory care programsMental wellnessMild cognitive impairmentMove-in helpMovie nightsMovie roomMusic programMusic programsNon-ambulatory careOn-site worshipOne-person transferOutdoor programsOutdoor spaceOutside hospice allowedPlanned activitiesPrivate bathroomProfessional chefResident parkingResident-run clubsRespite careRestaurant-style diningRoom phoneShort staysSpaSpecial dietsTransport and parkingTransport arrangedVegetarianWalking pathsWheelchair accessibleWheelchair usersWi-FiWorks with your doctors

Daily life

Dining & meals

ASeveral accounts

“The lunch we had was quite good and people were friendly.”
A Place for Mom, Aug 11, 2026
9 more reviews · 37 listed features
“For #6, the food looks amazing, but we haven't tried it yet.”
A Place for Mom, Jul 21, 2026
“Whether enjoying a delicious meal, working out at the gym, watching a movie or sharing a cup of coffee it is all part of a wonderful experience.”
Google, Apr 28, 2026
“The activities, dining, and services are exactly what you would want for a loved one, and the studio designs are among the best I have seen.”
Google, Apr 23, 2026
“We tried a meal at one of the dining rooms, and it felt just like we were out at a nice restaurant.”
Google, Dec 9, 2025
“The dining is excellent with 2 restaurants and a bar (with live music multiple times a week).”
A Place for Mom, Oct 14, 2025
“The food is good.”
A Place for Mom, Oct 9, 2025
“I will say that she said she was very well cared for, the food was excellent and she appreciated the availability of transportation and activities.”
A Place for Mom, Oct 2, 2025
“Besides the filters being as bad as they are I also noticed the floors in the main dining room be severely scratched and poorly maintained.”
A Place for Mom, Aug 11, 2025
“Besides the filters being as bad as they are I also noticed the floors in the main dining room be severely scratched and poorly maintained.”
Google, Jun 20, 2025
  • Cooking Classes
  • Cooking Club
  • All day dining
  • Allergy-aware
  • Anytime Dining
  • Bar or Pub
  • Café
  • Café
  • Communal Dining
  • Diabetes diet
  • Dining room
  • Gluten-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Grill
  • Guest Meals
  • International cuisine
  • International Cuisine
  • Low sodium
  • Low sodium
  • Meal preparation and service
  • Meals Provided
  • Menu highlights
  • No Sugar
  • Organic
  • Private Dining Room
  • Professional chef
  • Professional Chef
  • Restaurant-style dining
  • Restaurant-style dining
  • Room Service
  • Special diets
  • Special Dining Programs
  • Sports / cocktail lounge
  • Lounge bar
  • Meals, snacks and prescribed diets
  • Vegan
  • Vegetarian

ASeveral accounts

“FOOD: I have visited but have not participated in any meals.”
Caring, Nov 2, 2024
4 more reviews · 14 listed features
“I saw the menu.”
Caring, Sep 7, 2024
“As Powers of Attorney for our sister, we are thankful for the loving, mindful, efficient and consistent care our sister receives and love the amount of time Portola Gardens puts into the wellbeing and socializing of their Residents with quality activities and homemade healthy food!”
Seniorly, Dec 23, 2023
“She the food all the time and it smells good.”
Caring, Jul 22, 2019
“The menu looks good and they offer different options for different dietary needs.”
A Place for Mom, Feb 7, 2017
  • All day dining
  • Allergy-aware
  • Diabetes diet
  • Dining room
  • Gluten-free
  • Kosher
  • Kosher meals
  • Meal preparation and service
  • Meals Provided
  • Professional chef
  • Restaurant-style dining
  • Special diets
  • Meals, snacks and prescribed diets
  • Vegetarian

Activities & social life

ASeveral accounts

“I feel cared for by our superb staff, feel engaged in our diverse activities, entertained by so many events and pleasantly surrounded by friendly and interesting fellow residents.”
CareScout, Jun 27, 2026
4 more reviews · 59 listed features
“The activities, dining, and services are exactly what you would want for a loved one, and the studio designs are among the best I have seen.”
Google, Apr 23, 2026
“The dining is excellent with 2 restaurants and a bar (with live music multiple times a week).”
A Place for Mom, Oct 14, 2025
“There are exercise classes and the swimming pool is great.”
A Place for Mom, Oct 9, 2025
“I will say that she said she was very well cared for, the food was excellent and she appreciated the availability of transportation and activities.”
A Place for Mom, Oct 2, 2025
  • Activities Off-site
  • Activities On-site
  • Adventist Services
  • Art Classes
  • BBQs or picnics
  • Birthday Parties
  • Book Club
  • Bridge Club
  • Card club
  • Catholic Services
  • Choir
  • Christian Services
  • Community activities
  • Lifelong learning
  • Cooking Classes
  • Cooking Club
  • Current Events Club
  • Dances
  • Day trips
  • Outings
  • On-site worship
  • Talks and classes
  • Outings
  • Fitness programs
  • Gardening Club
  • Happy Hour
  • Holiday Parties
  • Intergenerational events
  • Islamic Services
  • Jewish Services
  • Karaoke
  • Light Therapy Programs
  • Live shows
  • Live music
  • Live Well Programs
  • Mormon/LDS Services
  • Movie nights
  • Music program
  • Music programs
  • Religious services
  • Outdoor programs
  • Pet-focused Programs
  • Planned activities
  • Protestant Services
  • Qi Gong
  • Reminiscence Programs
  • Resident musicians
  • Resident-run clubs
  • Daily activities
  • Stretching Classes
  • Tai Chi
  • Trivia Games
  • Visiting clergy
  • Visiting Rabbi
  • Walking Club
  • Water Aerobics
  • Wine Tasting
  • Chair yoga
  • Activity room

ASeveral accounts

“ACTIVITIES: Those that I have observed seem to fit the needs of the residents.”
Caring, Nov 2, 2024
7 more reviews · 14 listed features
“Just walking into the facility, you could tell that they had a lot of activities going on, and everybody was very engaged.”
Caring, Sep 7, 2024
“Our family is beyond grateful for the exquisite care our sister is receiving from the nursing staff, the activities coordinators and especially Lynda Connelly who has been a pillar of support and professionalism alongside the rest of the Executive & Business Staff.”
Seniorly, Dec 23, 2023
“They did have a big activity area; they had quite a few.”
Caring, Dec 15, 2023
“They did have activities going on, but not many.”
Caring, Mar 6, 2023
“I recommended them to a couple of my friends' moms.”
Caring, Jul 22, 2019
“It has a large day room for residents with lounger chairs to rest and watch television, listen to music or play games.”
A Place for Mom, Dec 10, 2017
“They have daily activities and the community is very clean.”
A Place for Mom, Feb 7, 2017
  • Activities Off-site
  • Activities On-site
  • Community activities
  • Off-site worship
  • On-site worship
  • Fitness programs
  • Movie nights
  • Music program
  • Music programs
  • Outdoor programs
  • Planned activities
  • Resident-run clubs
  • Daily activities
  • Activity room

Outdoor time

CLimited detail

9 listed features
  • Gardening Club
  • Outdoor programs
  • Garden
  • Outdoor space
  • Outdoor space
  • Patio
  • Patio
  • Raised Garden Beds
  • Walking paths

ASeveral accountsMore detail

“We chose Portola Gardens to care for our mom during her time in hospice, and overall, we’re grateful we found this facility when we needed it most.”
Google, Jul 9, 2025
11 more reviews · 5 listed features
“I toured Portola Gardens.”
Caring, Sep 7, 2024
“I toured Portola Gardens.”
Caring, Jul 31, 2024
“Portola Gardens Assisted Living in San Francisco has been the biggest gift to our sister and family.”
Seniorly, Dec 23, 2023
“The tour at Portola Gardens was good.”
Caring, Dec 15, 2023
“Portola Gardens was a terrible place.”
Caring, Mar 6, 2023
“Portola Garden was there in a pinch.”
Google, Nov 17, 2022
“Portola Gardens was huge.”
Caring, Nov 12, 2022
“I went to Portola Gardens.”
Caring, Dec 5, 2021
“Portola Gardens is a gorgeous old historic building in San Francisco.”
Caring, May 25, 2021
“My family member resided at Portola Gardens for 4 years.”
Google, Apr 16, 2021
“Portola Gardens is beautiful, wonderful, and the staff is excellent.”
Caring, Jul 22, 2019
  • Outdoor programs
  • Garden
  • Outdoor space
  • Outdoor space
  • Walking paths

Quiet & privacy

?Ask on tour

BTwo sources of detailMore detail

“ROOMS: The rooms are quiet and clean Residents do not need to bring their own furniture.”
Caring, Nov 2, 2024
1 more review
“The bedroom faced the backyard, which allowed privacy, a view of the trees and the ability to admire the flowers during the Spring and Summer seasons, and fresh air from the window.”
Google, Apr 16, 2021

Outings & transportation

ASeveral accountsMore detail

“She plans great outings and creates such a fun, positive atmosphere for the residents.”
Google, Jul 16, 2026
2 more reviews · 10 listed features
“We're beginning to look around for a facility for my grandma, who is suffering from dementia, and seeing all of the events, outings and everyone's kindness with the residents helps make my family feel confident that my grandparents would be very well taken care of!”
Google, Jul 4, 2026
“I will say that she said she was very well cared for, the food was excellent and she appreciated the availability of transportation and activities.”
A Place for Mom, Oct 2, 2025
  • Day trips
  • Outings
  • Outings
  • Transport arranged
  • Free transportation
  • Covered Parking
  • Transportation
  • Near public transit
  • Resident parking
  • Transport and parking

CLimited detail

4 listed features
  • Transport arranged
  • Free transportation
  • Resident parking
  • Transport and parking

Pets & visiting animals

CLimited detail

6 listed features
  • Pet-focused Programs
  • Cats Allowed
  • Dogs Allowed
  • Pet Care Available
  • Pet-friendly
  • Pets

CLimited detail

5 listed features
  • Cats Allowed
  • Dogs Allowed
  • Pet Care Available
  • Pet-friendly
  • Pets

Coterie Cathedral Hill or Portola Gardens? Common questions

Ask on your visits

More comparisons in San Francisco

Get help with my shortlist